Avoiding legal issues when planning profit extraction
Directors often have misconceptions regarding their remuneration. This can sometimes have serious consequences. What does a recent High Court decision underline the importance of understanding when taking money out of a company?
Insolvency case
The High Court case of Bass and Ors v Buchanan [2021] EWHC 2740 (Ch) involved an overdrawn director’s loan account in a company providing client representation for actors. Profitability fell significantly and HMRC demanded all outstanding unpaid tax. Remuneration
The director’s remuneration pattern was typical of many small companies, the director taking low salary and high dividends. She drew money monthly from the company via standing order. After some years, there were not sufficient distributable profits to vote dividends to cover monthly drawings and the director’s loan account remained overdrawn.
Where a director’s loan account is outstanding more than nine months after the company year end, the question of corporation tax under s.455 Corporation Tax Act 2010 arises.
It’s a bright line from a tax angle, but in practice boundaries can get muddy, and this happened here. The company accountant asked their client to sign a declaration that the overdrawn loan account would be repaid instead of declaring a s.455 charge to HMRC. The loan was never repaid. The result was that the company was put into liquidation, and its sole director held liable to repay the outstanding balance on the director’s loan account - over £280,000, plus interest.
Communications
This case showed how great misunderstandings can be about the legal position when trading via a limited company. It is crucial the fact that monies drawn from the company are only on account until covered as dividends or salary. Where payments are not made as salary in real time, or if there aren’t sufficient profits from which to pay dividends, by default, monies stand to be treated as a loan.
Tthe company exists as a legal entity separate from its director, and that extracting cash from a company is completely different from taking drawings from a sole trader or partnership business. It’s not a simple ratio of hours worked to monies out; remuneration has to be voted and documented correctly.
Related Topics
-
Founders' relief: a closer look
The Budget's new Founders' Relief sounds remarkably generous, offering a 10% capital gains tax rate on up to £10 million of gains from selling shares from April 2027. However, a closer look at the proposed qualifying conditions suggests that relatively few business owners will benefit. Why might the relief be so difficult to claim?
-
MONTHLY FOCUS: 2026 BUDGET SPECIAL
Budget 2026 contains a mixture of tax rises, new reliefs and changes to the way businesses and individuals will be taxed from 2027 onwards. Savings and property income will face higher rates, the lifetime limit for Business Asset Disposal Relief will fall, a new founders' relief is planned and several allowances and business incentives are changing. Which measures matter most, and is there anything you should do before they take effect?
-
Autumn Budget 2026 – what are the key tax announcements?
The Chancellor delivered the Autumn Budget on 28 October, announcing a mixture of tax increases, new reliefs and changes to the way tax is administered. Although the headline rates of income tax, National Insurance (NI) and VAT remain unchanged, there are some significant changes affecting business owners, landlords and private individuals. What are the main announcements?
This website uses both its own and third-party cookies to analyze our services and navigation on our website in order to improve its contents (analytical purposes: measure visits and sources of web traffic). The legal basis is the consent of the user, except in the case of basic cookies, which are essential to navigate this website.